Carbone's Pizza & Subs

Marcus Williams Jr 2 months ago

I live down the street and this is a very convenient place - they're open late, they're friendly, and the food is good. They might not be the cleanest place, but sometimes that's where you get the best food. Most nights, it's very busy but the staff just keeps the orders moving along and gets the customers in and out. Everyone is very nice - it's classic Buffalo. Pictured is a custom pizza I ordered - large white pizza with garlic crust, oil & garlic base, pepperoni, sausage, and bacon. Our wings were cooked perfectly. I don't even need to ask for extra crispy because they cook them crispy enough for my liking already. They also have pizza by the slice with classic or sweet sauce.

Li Karaian 2 months ago

Expensive fries! A small bowl is $5 dollars. Service is slower than expected, it came up as fast food in my search but waited 20 mins for wings, fries and a wrap.

Gary Hofmann 3 months ago

Found this cool Pizza and Subs place when we were looking for a place to eat off the main highway! The place is really cool and the regular pizza was authentic and good! They offer a sweet pie slice too but didn’t try it! The Cheesesteak was delicious and beats a Philly by a mile! The place was old with character and the staff was friendly and it was quick! We will be back on another road trip from maryland to Canada!

Eric Wade Edited 5 months ago

Bomb!!! 🧨💣 As JJ Would say on an old episode of "Good TIMES" - - - DYNaOMITE 🤣... This truly is the best 🍕 pizza ever in BUFFALO 🦬! Why 😯 do think that been there around 50 years! #D-Lish as Rachael Rae would say. Years back my GF Joanne Grange introduced me to this place! Man are they good!!!! If you don't order from them then I just suppose that you just don't know what you are missing out on !!! This restaurant is a great Pillar to the Buffalo community in Erie county it smashes all of their competitors out of the water 💦

Buffalo Butt 8 months ago

I give all establishments 3 strikes before I put them on my personal ban list. They were on my list but because I was in a time crunch, I went against my better judgement and....they earned their 4th strike. They don't have any real standards when it comes to their pies or cleanliness of the establishment; I'd hate to see what the walk-in looks like. Their wings. The wings are terrible and no matter how much you ask, or what instructions you give, they cook them to their standard. Funny that they have standards for making bad wings but nothing else. They are not crispy at all! The flavors are good, very good but that skin?.....🤢 I've asked for crispy. I've asked for extra crispy. Today I specifically asked for them to be cooked for 2 min longer, but every time, they've given me rubbery vomit inducing chicken skin. FYI: I actually open my box until I get home, to let steam out. People love them, and they've been around for decades. Admittedly, they were ALOT better in the 90's. However, for me, If you need CRISP wings, this is not the place to come. The pizza....Every time I've eaten it, it was made different from the previous time. (An inconsistent way of cooking a dish will pro